• Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Tailster Blog

Tailster

  • Dogs
  • Cats
  • Walkers & Sitters
Tailster / Dogs / Useful Dog Tips / Dog Walking / Collar vs Harness: Which Is Right For You?

Collar vs Harness: Which Is Right For You?

There are many opinions out there when it comes to the collar vs harness debate. Ultimately it comes down to the specific breed and what works best for your dog but we’ve got some Tailster Tips to help you make the choice.

Contents hide
1 Collars
1.1 Pros
1.2 Cons
2 Harness
2.1 Pros
2.2 Cons
3 We’d recommend investing in both

orion small 2 18

Collars

Pros

Convenient for ID tags: A collar is the perfect place to attach your dog’s ID tag. Legally, your dog must wear an identification tag with your name and full postcode (your phone number is optional but highly recommended!)

Some dogs prefer collars: A collar is an excellent alternative for dog’s who don’t feel comfortable in a harness.

Cons

Increased chance of injury: Even a dog who pulls fairly lightly can be at a higher risk of injuring the neck or spine. Read our guide on how to stop lead pulling here.

Increased eye pressure: Collars have been know to cause increased eye pressure which can worsen any existing eye problems.

Not as secure: If your dog is spooked or panicked, they will find it far easier to slip out and escape from a collar than a secure chest harness.

Harness

Pros

Great training tool for puppies: Harnesses are a great option when training a young puppy not to pull as you have better control over your dog.

Perfect for flat faced breed: Brachycephalics such as French Bulldogs and Pugs, can develop respiratory stress if too much pressure is put on their throat and necks.

Cons

Harnesses can rub: Some breeds might find an ill fitting harness uncomfortable under the arm pit area. Always ensure your harness fits your dog correctly by measuring before you buy.

See also  Here Are All The Dog Walking Rules That You Need

Can’t be worn at all times: It wouldn’t be fair on your dog if you insisted on the harness being worn at all hours of the day. Your dog’s harness should just be worn for their walks!

We’d recommend investing in both

Collar for home: Your dog should have ID tags on 24/7. A collar is comfortable enough to be worn all day long so you’re prepared in case of an escape.

Harness for walks: A correctly fitted harness reduces risk of injury or choking and lessens the chance of your dog slipping out into danger.

bones banner tailster shadow 1

Work, family and social commitments mean that there often aren’t enough hours in the day to give our pets the attention that they deserve. Click here to find out how Tailster can put you in contact with hundreds of pet carers in your local area, meaning that you can rest in the knowledge that your pets are being well looked after

21st August 2021

Footer

  • Book a carer
  • Become a carer
  • About
  • Contact

Affiliate Disclosure

We believe in being as transparent as possible when it comes to this site. With this in mind, please be aware that we may receive remuneration for some of the products we review on this site.

Tailster is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com (and other Amazon programs).

We will also list ads from time to time. You should be able to see these as text links or blocks of ads which have a small notation indicating “Ads by Google” or “AdChoices”.

Our mission is to help our visitors, but this is also very clearly a for-profit site and you should realize as much. We include only those products that we believe could benefit you, some of which we may get a commission if you purchase them. However, we also provide links on the site to information resources for which we receive no compensation.

If you have any questions whatsoever, please contact us using the "contact" option on the site menu and we will be happy to answer any questions.

Trademark Dislosure

Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc, or its affiliates.

In addition, any other trademarks and logos we mention on this site are also the property of their respective owners.

Copyright © 2025 Tailster